• Comment

Government: Education system rife with inequities

Posted: March 22, 2014 - 3:09pm

WASHINGTON (AP) — Sixty years ago, the Supreme Court ruled that black children have the right to the same education as their white peers.

But civil rights data released Friday by the Education Department reflect an education system rife with inequities for blacks and other minority students and those with disabilities.

Minority students are less likely to have access to advanced math and science classes and veteran teachers. Black students of any age, even the youngest preschoolers, are more likely to be suspended. And students with disabilities are more likely than other students to be tied down or placed alone in a room as a form of discipline.

“It is clear that the United States has a great distance to go to meet our goal of providing opportunities for every student to succeed,” said Education Secretary Arne Duncan.

But the department offered no explanation of why these disparities exist.

Here are five things to know about the department’s findings:


STEM is the buzzword in education these days. Education in the fields of science, technology and engineering and math is considered critical for students to succeed in the global marketplace. Yet the department found that there was a “significant lack of access” to core classes like algebra, geometry, biology and chemistry for many students. That lack of access was particularly striking when it came to minorities.

“A quarter of high schools with the highest percentage of black and Latino students do not offer Algebra II; a third of these schools do not offer chemistry,” the department said.

And it’s not just lack of access to core curriculum subjects.

Only a quarter of black and Latino students were enrolled in an Advanced Placement class, which allows high school students to earn college credit, and fewer than 1 in 5 scored high enough generally to get college credit.

Even as black and Latino students represent 40 percent of the enrollment in schools offering gifted and talented programs, they represent only a quarter of the students in their schools enrolled in them.

Christopher Emdin, a professor of science education at Teachers College, Columbia University, said if a school doesn’t offer advanced math and science classes, students are told they are not expected to take those classes.

“There is nothing more severe in contemporary America, particularly as it relates to youth of color, than the soft bigotry of low expectations,” Emdin said. “These inequities in the availability of science and math classes show young people that not much is expected of them. It highlights a subtle and severe bias that we will collectively suffer from as our STEM jobs continue to go unfilled, and our young people refuse to be scientists and engineers.


Quality teachers can play a key role in student performance.

Minority students are more likely to attend schools with a higher concentration of first-year teachers than white students. And while most teachers are certified, nearly half a million students nationally attend schools where nearly two-thirds or fewer of teachers meet all state certification and licensing requirements. Black and Latino students are more likely than white students to attend these schools.

There’s also a teacher salary gap of more than $5,000 between high schools with the highest and lowest black and Latino students enrollments, according to the data.

Maddie Fennell, a literacy coach at Miller Park Elementary, an urban school in Omaha, Neb., said that too often in teaching, the mindset is that the more experienced a teacher is, the more deserving the teacher is of a less-challenging school environment. She said this doesn’t make sense because, in comparison, an experienced surgeon wouldn’t be given the healthiest patients. Ultimately, she said, the most qualified teachers will request to follow strong principals.

“A lot of it has to do with the leadership of a (school) building,” Fennell said.


The Obama administration issued guidance earlier this year encouraging schools to abandon what it described as overly zealous discipline policies that send students to court instead of the principal’s office, the so-called schools-to-prisons pipeline. But even before the announcement, school districts had been adjusting policies that disproportionately affected minority students. The civil rights data released Friday from the 2011-2012 school year show the disparities begin among even the youngest of school kids. Black children represent about 18 percent of children in preschool programs in schools, but they make up almost half of the preschoolers who are suspended more than once. Six percent of the nation’s districts with preschools reported suspending at least one preschool child.

Overall, the data show that black students of all ages are suspended and expelled at a rate that’s three times higher than that of white children. Even as boys receive more than two-thirds of suspensions, black girls are suspended at higher rates than girls of any other race or most boys. More than half of students involved in school-related arrests or referred to law enforcement were Hispanic or black.


“Seclusion and restraint” is a term used to describe when students are strapped down or physically restrained in schools. The data show students with disabilities represent about 12 percent of the student population, but about 60 percent of students placed in seclusion or involuntary confinement and three quarters of students restrained at school. While black students make up about 1 in 5 students with disabilities, more than one-third of the students who are restrained at school are black. Overall, the data show that more than 37,000 students were placed in seclusion, and 4,000 students with disabilities were held in place by a mechanical restraint.

Democrats Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, and Rep. George Miller, D-Calif., have unsuccessfully fought for a federal law for years to end the practice. National associations representing school boards and superintendents have said such legislation would reduce the authority of states and districts, but that seclusion and restraint should only be used as a last resort to protect school staff and students.


The Obama administration views access to preschool as a civil rights issue. It says 40 percent of school districts offer preschool programs. Their numbers don’t include private programs or some other types of publicly funded early childhood programs outside of school systems. Obama has sought a “preschool for all” program with the goal of providing universal preschool to America’s 4-year-olds that would use funding from a hike in tobacco taxes.

  • Comment
Comments (4) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
sevenof400 03/23/14 - 08:06 am
Why should equal outcomes be expected...

....when students enter the system on an unequal basis?
The education system should not be held responsible for parental failure.

reader 03/23/14 - 08:41 am
Got to ditto that 400

Teachers are there with a plan to educate. The kids should come prepared for learning, but so often do not. Don't blame the teachers, they endure enough for their paygrade.

David 03/23/14 - 11:02 am
Seclusion and restraint

Why can't we just have fast and easy solutions for every complex and multifaceted problem? Education is easy enough to describe; it's extraordinarily difficult to do. Parenting is easy to describe; it's extraordinarily difficult to do. Amazingly enough, not every parent can be an educator and not every educator can be a parent. However, we do have exceptionally high expectations for our educators so we ask them to get some preparation and a license before we turn them lose on our little darlings. On the other hand, we also have exceptionally high expectations for parents so we do nothing to prepare them and, God forbid, we certainly don't require them to have a license to parent. Not to worry, we can strap the kids down, place them in seclusion, label them with "disabilities," and send them off for the legal system to deal with. Maybe we're using our tactics of restraint in the wrong place and on the wrong side of the problem. Employing the always useful sports analogy, maybe requiring that every kickoff be run back for a touchdown isn't reasonable. Maybe our problems with education are what they are because some of what we did in the past worked well and some didn't. Maybe we could explore what worked and stop jumping from one panacea to another.

crypted quill
crypted quill 03/23/14 - 12:55 pm
You can always fall back on

You can always fall back on the School voucher programs...

[10 Insane History Lessons that Private, Religious Voucher Schools Are Teaching America’s Kids]


1. The Great Depression: Made Up to Spread Socialism
2. Nazis: Brought to you by Karl Marx and Charles Darwin
3. The Post-WWII Era: A Time of Crusades and Constant Praying
4. The '60s and '70s: Everything Goes to S***, Mainly Because the State Stops Killing Born People and Starts Killing Pre-Born Babies and... Freud.
5. Freedom of Speech: Gateway to Porn


[Beka Book]

1. Clarence Thomas: Greatest Example of Black American Achievement Yet
2. Ronald Reagan: Finally! A Non-Loser Patriot for President
3. The Clintons: Draft-Dodging, Economic-Crisis-Creating, Joint Presidents
4. George W. Bush: Awesome President Invades Iraq and Saves Mid-Born Babies
5. Barack Obama: Great for the Homosexuals

Back to Top