Brawner: Will it take a crisis to fix the debt?

Steve Brawner

Rahm Emanuel, once President Obama’s chief of staff and now mayor of Chicago, told corporate executives in 2008, “You never want a serious crisis to go to waste. And what I mean by that, it’s an opportunity to do things that you think you could not do before.”


That quote has been used to criticize Emanuel, but it’s often certainly been true for this democracy. When something is merely a big problem, action can be delayed even if that delay causes great harm in the future. A crisis, however, demands a response. The country didn’t get involved in World War II until Japan bombed Pearl Harbor, and it didn’t really get serious about the space race until the Russians took the lead.

This past week, the Obama administration announced that the fiscal year 2013 deficit will be $759 billion. Meanwhile, the national debt — what’s been accumulating since 1835, the last time the government didn’t owe anybody anything — is now $16.7 trillion, or $53,000 for every American man, woman and child.

The national debt is what we owe; deficits are what we add each year to what we owe.

This $759 billion deficit is being treated in many quarters as good news because it’s the smallest one-year deficit in the past five years, when $1 trillion became the norm. At 4.7 percent of the gross domestic product, it’s also much smaller as a percentage of the economy than 2009’s deficit, which was 10.1 percent of GDP.

However, the deficits were only a big problem, not a crisis, so Congress tried to manufacture one by giving itself a deadline to act. Remember the fiscal cliff? Unfortunately, a fake crisis wasn’t enough to do the job.

Here’s another thing about human nature: It has a funny way of comparing things. There was a time when $759 billion would have seemed like a big problem, almost a crisis. But now that we’ve gotten used to $1 trillion, a number like $759 billion seems like good news. The pressure to act, temporarily, is gone. And now that we’ve gotten used to $1 trillion, how much will it take for that pressure to return?

Clearly, an improving economy is a good thing. People need jobs and paychecks right now, so we shouldn’t be Eeyore the donkey saying things are worse when for many, they’re better.

Neither should we be Tigger the tiger, hopping around because this year’s deficit is “only” $759 billion. That’s $2,400 in new debt for every American man, woman and child.

So it’s looking like it’s going to take a crisis — a real one, not a fake one — to fix the debt. Unless attitudes change (and maybe human nature, too), Americans will pretend the problem doesn’t exist until the country suffers the fiscal equivalent of Pearl Harbor.

Steve Brawner is an independent journalist in Arkansas. His email address is Follow him on Twitter at @stevebrawner.



Wed, 12/13/2017 - 10:58

Guest Column: Legalize Gambling in the State of Arkansas

The state of Arkansas voted in November of 2008 to legalize the sale of lottery tickets in the name of scholarship money for higher education. Arkansas should legalize gambling in casinos as well because of the increase in tax revenues both locally and state wide, as well as other benefits the decision would carry. According to statistics provided by, the two commercial casinos in our neighboring state of Oklahoma are taxed at rates of up to 30 percent on gaming revenues, and at a 9 percent rate on horse racing revenues. This increase in tax revenue could mean many great things for the state of Arkansas and its communities.

Read more